The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power

Viewing 15 posts - 31 through 45 (of 93 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #258205

     

    #258279

    #259423

    The Radical Politics of J.R.R. Tolkien

    Lauren Southern

    #259853

    Amazon must be really desperate to do something like this🙄:

    Some people can’t take a joke these days🙄…

    #259883

    When they themselves and the stuff they are pandering IS A JOKE of horrible proportions who desecrates the source material…

    The Rings of Woke is trash.

    I do hope the people (actors, technical people, etc. – but NOT the producers/writers/directors) have guaranteed contracts that they will be paid the full amount regardless of when it gets cancelled in the suggested five seasons planned.

    As it is standing now, this will be the biggest budgeted streaming show FLOP in history.

    #275761

    Bumping in anticipation of trailer release in the next 48 hours.

    #275773

    You can drink your fancy ales,
    You can drink them by the flagon,
    But the only brew for the brave and true…
    ..Comes from the Green Dragon!”
    — Tolkien

    Was The Green Dragon Inn of The Shire based on the Tavern where the American revolutionaries met in secret?

    The Green Dragon Tavern was a public house located on Union Street in Boston’s North End. A popular meeting place for both the Freemasons and the Sons of Liberty, it was demolished in 1832. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Dragon_Tavern

     

     

    #275790
    Mustangride1
    Moderator

      @Comicsgate
      To answer your question “Was The Green Dragon Inn of The Shire based on the Tavern where the American revolutionaries met in secret?
      NO

      The answer is in Letter 163:
      “I first tried to write a story when I was about seven. It was about a dragon. I remember nothing
      about it except a philological fact. My mother said nothing about the dragon, but pointed out that
      one could not say ‘a green great dragon’, but had to say ‘a great green dragon’. I wondered why, and
      still do. The fact that I remember this is possibly significant, as I do not think I ever tried to write a
      story again for many years, and was taken up with language.”

      It was taken from his youth, his mother’s words and her starting him on the path of language. Certainly a 7 year old British Boy would have no knowledge of Revolutionary Tavern.. Although given the name “The Green Dragon Inn” in all reality it was probably based at least loosely on “The Eagle and Child” the tavern the Inklings gathered at.

      It is nice to have Tolkien’s letters look to for possible answers and this one appears to be spelled out to the Name a knod to his mother and if you look at the “Bird” the name they gave to “The Eagle and Child” it can quickly be compared, as it is where the Inklings played with ideas for their books and in fact, The Prancing Pony is where Frodo himself said “He was thinking of writing a book.”

      Though the “Green Dragon” is in The Shire, It is only mentioned 5 times, between the Hobbit and LOTR, and not at all in Tolkien’s Letters or the Silmarilion.

      Though some could argue its the Tavern in Bilbos Song. Though that is most certainly from the Nursery Rime “Hey Diddle Diddle” from 1765.

      #275937

      I guess this is what a billion dollars buys today.

      #275948
      Mustangride1
      Moderator

        This is NOT Tolkien this is Amazon and their social agenda, inclusion and diversity.

        What wars did Lady Galadriel, From the Dawn of time until the 3rd Age fight in?

        Since when do female dwarfs not have beards? The Return of the King, Appendix A Black Elves and Dwarfs? Not in Tolkien’s descriptions of them. And certainly not in the Lore from which he drew his stories from.  He was specific about that per (letter 131)

        Sauron’s eye is 3RD AGE which this show is not suppose to even touch. per The Lord of the Rings, The Return of the King, Book Six, Chapter II: “The Land of Shadow”

        Wizards did not come by a Comet.  per The Silmarillion, Of the Rings of Power

        Harfoots are there only so people can say HEY LOOK HOBBITS!

        #275953

        This is NOT J.R.R.Tolkein’s work.

        remember, they even say it in the trailer:

        Based off of…

        It is NOT an adaption of any of J.R.R.Tolkein’s work.

         

        So I can see what is gonna happen.  Amazon wanted their own GoT, and they are gonna get season 8 of GoT… something HATED by fans alike.

        #275997

        @Legatus_Legionis

        That’s why I got so confused with the last trailer. If this is supposed to be their ‘Game of Thrones’- complete with sex, nudity and bloody violence- then why was there a KID watching it??? Even though he’s probably seen worse on his XBox

        #276004
        Mustangride1
        Moderator

          @DragonLady

          Who knows what they will do with this perversion of Tolkien’s works…. I wont be watching it, but will take pleasure in the revues and comments destroying it.

          This more than any other thing hollywood has done proves there is no more Creators left in Hollywood. They had all His FINISHED, <YES I said finished> works, letters and interviews explaining in great detail what he wanted or was trying to achieve. They had a unlimited budget to make it RIGHT and clearly all the time in the world to. Yet this is the crap they gave the world.

          You know what is the saddest part. It is they could have made the first trillion dollar Series,  had they just stuck to the professors works. Now they have angered more than half the audience, and people are cancelling PRIME….

          Let me address the cancelling prime comments… When you do that you are hurting yourself, its foolish to cancel something with free delivery in this world especially in this economy. Yes by all means do not watch anything on PRIME VIDEO… But also use your brains people… Shipping is NOT cheap and even if you do it one time and then figure it out you still hurt yourself once. Make your displeasure known in Lack of ratings, comments and dislikes avoid buying from them when possible. But do not harm yourself or families finances to show your ass, or you are as big a fools as they are.

          #276045

          Know how to *really* piss off the SJWs and get some media coverage? Use either premiere or davinci or vegas to recolor the black elves to white as per Tolkien’s desciptions. It’s a simple curve adjustment. Release to the internet as a “purist cut” or so, wait for heads to explode.

          #276061

          @Mustangride1

          I’ve seen better TV shows with £1 Billion budgets. The excellent 1998 ‘Hornblower’ TV series with Ioan Grufford being one of them. And the best part? It had little to no CGI in it and the boats they were on and using were REAL!

        Viewing 15 posts - 31 through 45 (of 93 total)
        • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

        Subscribe to our mailing list to get the new updates!

        SIGN UP FOR UPDATES!

        NAVIGATION