Rogue One A Star Wars Story an very good Star Wars Movie?

no.

Tarkin should not be younger. the film ended 30 minuets before the start of Star Wars. And dont get me started on the chick pretending to be Carrie. that looked even fucking cheaper.

The mumbling fuck in the male lead needed subtitles.
The fuck in the white cape does not exist in canon.
The battle of shitriff actually proves that the incident in the limp jedi couldnt happen… ship tries to enter hyperspace and collides with the Devastator. Not a fucking thing happens to the big D the rebel ship turns to scrap.

Frankly the only good part of the film was the 45 seconds of Vader going apeshit in that hallway. Yet even that is fucked cause he should have grabbed the keycard in the force and either crushed it or pulled it out of the dudes hand.

I’m in the middle here. The director is really good with scaling things and made the Death Star look large and menacing in a way that was different than what we’ve seen before. I also think there exists some director’s version of the movie that is probably really good. What we got was decent, but flawed. I thought the space battle was well done. Of course Vader’s scene was horror at its best (even if it makes little sense for the plot). The way the character’s died annoyed me: as soon as the plot didn’t need them anymore, random grenade!

Ultimately, it’s the best Disney Star Wars movie we’ve been given but that doesn’t make it a masterpiece like the original trilogy.

Rogue One by far is the best Disney Star Wars movie.  I like it a lot actually.  You could see how KK wanted to go the feminist route with Jyn being female, etc.  However, Felicity Jones actually played the role in such a way that you didn’t feel like it was crammed down your throat.  It was actually a good move by Felicity too because if you notice, she isn’t hated by people like Brie Larson.  I kind of give Daisy Ridley a pass.  Daisy seems to be a nice person in real life, but my God, they gave her an awful role.  They made Rey such a Mary Sue, I really don’t think there was a way Daisy could soften the blow.

Back back to Rogue One.  I think it is a worthy addition to the Canon.

As for the Force Awakens, The Last Jedi, and the Rise of Palpatine —- I think those should be burned and buried in a hole.  Those movies are so bad.  I rewatched Mauler’s videos the other days and I had forgotten how truly awful those movies where. (I refused to go see the Rise of Palpatine though.)  I saw enough video clips though.

Rogue One was far more tolerable than the other Disney movies. Granted, I would have preferred if they had left Kyle Katarn as part of the story in stealing the plans for the Death Star but oh well. One thing that I liked about it was how the mission was a suicide mission. None of the heroes survived to go on with the story. It gave a bit more weight to the sacrifice the Alliance had to make during the Galactic Civil War.

Rouge One is the only good movie that came out of Disney Star Wars

Did you not even like the Mandalorian? I think that’s the definition of good Star Wars. Not anything great, just good. I think it’s possible for them to make good Star Wars with the right people.

• This reply was modified 3 years, 9 months ago by DarthGregious.

Rogue One is the ONLY Disney Star Wars Film I will (and have) watch more than ONCE.

I liked how it showed the type of pressure the Empire can place on people, and how the average citizen dealt with it.

I liked h0w it showed some of the political maneuvering Imperial officers did.

I liked how it had a full and complete story arc.

It did things correctly the other Disney films failed so spectacularly from.