I watched it after all the good reviews. I will say, the first 3 episodes were *really* good. All scenes with the imperials were great. Up until the heist, the show was engaging. After the heist, it fell apart. Good acting, but the story became nonsensical. The revolution in particular was silly, and the prison episodes were tonally off and felt like they were trying to do a Schindler’s List in space, except none of it made sense.
But credit where it’s due, those first episodes are probably the best that Disney Star Wars has come up with so far. Even the pacing was almost good, which is rare for TV shows, which are usually stretched out to fill airtime.